Can Employees Feel Unique Yet Included? Why We Need Both

BY Michael Stahl | July 24, 2020

The reinvigorated racial-justice movement in America has given new energy to many parallel conversations, notably about cultivating workplace equity more broadly for people from underrepresented and underserved communities. Yet even the most open-minded, conscientious allies might require more insight about how to make this a reality. To start, they could try a little empathy about universal human needs.

“All humans have these two basic needs, and that is we want to belong–we want to be accepted and valued–but we also want to be unique, which means we want to be our full selves,” said Stefanie Johnson, author of the new book Inclusify: The Power of Uniqueness and Belonging to Build Innovative Teams, during a fireside chat during From Day One’s July virtual conference, The New Push for Workplace Equity. “Those core things, that are part of your identity. You don’t want to have to hide or mask at work.”

These dueling truths aren’t easy to accommodate, but leaders willing to take risks and create an environment for sometimes-uncomfortable conversations will reap the rewards of a more creative workforce, said Johnson, who also teaches at the University of Colorado Boulder’s Leeds School of Business.

Prof. Johnson, at right, in a From Day One interview with Lydia Dishman of Fast Company (Image by From Day One)

“It’s easy to have everyone belong when you’re all the same, or it’s easy to all be yourselves when you don’t care about creating a cohesive team,” Johnson said, “but the magic is really in finding a way as a leader to allow people to belong, but as their true, best self.”

For the employee, this can begin at the very start of the hiring process. Speaking with Lydia Dishman, a writer and editor at Fast Company, Johnson suggested that corporate leaders rethink their recruiting approach.

Many well-meaning leaders and their HR staff might declare the goal of hiring simply “the best person” for the job and strip away concern over race or gender in the process, Johnson observed. But the leaders doing the hiring might be better served by parsing through their criteria, examining it on a more granular level, while being mindful of inherent bias within each of those prerequisites.

“Probably the biggest thing that I’ve done that has changed people’s mindset is showing them who they would end up with if they selected based on totally anonymized résumés–or just based on whatever it is that they define as merit–and then comparing that to the people that they actually chose,” Johnson said. “And then when there’s this huge disparity–and there usually is–it kind of shocks people into the reality that maybe they were unwittingly using criteria that are not at all meritocratic, like similarity bias.”

Managers who are more intentional about identifying objective criteria for hiring could help change company culture in a positive direction. However, Dishman noted that many from “majority groups” and people with privilege seem to wonder why more progress doesn’t come from bottom-up initiatives–as if it’s easy for underserved, undervalued populaces to “rise up” and “take action” to achieve equality.

“Why would that argument not work?” Dishman asked Johnson, who examined the issue from a feminist perspective as one example. Citing the “Lean In” initiative, which began seven years ago, Johnson said, “We’ve seen the research since then that when women lean in, and they try to be just as aggressive and negotiate just as hard [as men], then they’re actually viewed negatively because they’re violating their gender roles.”

Walking the line between “competent” and “likable” is not only challenging but something women shouldn’t have to endure in the first place. “So I think that just shows that ‘just try harder’ doesn’t work,” Johnson said. She added that, in the case of racial injustice, society has set up “huge systemic barriers” that also make the “just try harder” outlook ineffective at providing people of color greater access to vital resources, such as money and education.

Johnson said corporate leaders should be actively hiring from diverse populations and, as part of the hiring process and beyond, asking them what they want to achieve and how they want to contribute. Leaders should follow up with constructed plans for accomplishing those goals and making sure diverse workers are considered for the crucial career-development steps: high-profile tasks, projects and positions.

Inclusion is telegraphed on the job in sometimes subtle ways. For example, leaders should valso be on the lookout in meetings for behavior that robs workers of feeling that they’re included, such as not being on the receiving end of eye contact, not being given the chance to speak, being spoken over, or having their ideas co-opted by someone else without the originator receiving proper credit. Johnson said that other team members not necessarily in positions of power should also do their part, noticing those same behaviors, and changing their own.

“It really is a team effort to be more inclusive,” Dishman noted, and there might not be a better time than now to start putting forth such efforts.

“The world, the workplace, everything has been torn down by COVID,” Johnson said. “We’re all doing things differently, and I think this is our opportunity to rebuild it in a way that’s more inclusive, more equitable, and just more effective.”

Editor's note: you can read a sample chapter of Johnson's new book here on From Day One.

Michael Stahl is a New York City-based freelance journalist, writer and editor. You can read more of his work at MichaelStahlWrites.com, follow him on Twitter @MichaelRStahl, and order his first book, the autobiography of Major League Baseball pitcher Bartolo Colón, at Abrams Books


RELATED STORIES

How to Create and Sustain a Growth Mindset to Nurture Talent

When Dr. Mary Murphy was working on her PhD at Stanford, she was mentored by Carol S. Dweck, best-selling author of Mindset: The New Psychology of Success, a book that covers the potential of individuals. Now a social psychologist, Murphy has taken the mindset concept a step further and for over a decade has studied how the “fixed” or "growth” mindset affects not only individuals, but groups of people. Murphy discussed research from her book, Cultures of Growth: How the New Science of Mindset Can Transform Individuals, Teams, and Organizations, and how it can help teams during a fireside chat at From Day One’s March Virtual Conference.Those with a fixed mindset, Murphy says, believe in being born with skills that can’t grow any further. While those with a growth mindset believe they can learn and grow into new abilities. When talking about teams, organizations, families—there is a similar mindset culture.In a fixed mindset culture, or a “culture of genius” as Murphy called it, the focus is on the star performers. The opposite is a “culture of growth” where there is a focus on continuous learning so anyone can grow and contribute. And it’s that culture of growth that organizations need.Idea SparkIn 2005 during her PhD program, Murphy clearly recalled when this group application of mindset sparked. She was at a grad student seminar supporting a friend, where a professor voiced his opinion about what the fatal flaw of this student’s work was. Another professor chimed in and disagreed, saying the fatal flaw was something else. In essence, it was a battle of which professor was right.“I saw what it was doing to my friend,” she said. “All of a sudden, he lost focus. He wasn’t able to answer questions.” Unfortunately, the experience was so painful that months later he hadn’t continued his work.Two weeks later, in a different seminar, she witnessed something else. Rather than critiquing the students about what was wrong, the professors offered ideas on how to grow the project. The effect was clear. “The students were able to respond totally differently,” Murphy said. “They were able to actually engage in the brainstorming, answer the questions, and they left motivated to dig in.”Reflecting on those two experiences or environments, she realized how much a group can impact an outcome. The harsh approach was not motivating at all. On the other hand, the mentality of growth and how we can all contribute really turned things around for the better.Dr. Mary Murphy discussed her new book Cultures of Growth: How the New Science of Mindset Can Transform Individuals, Teams, and Organizations in a fireside chat moderated by From Day One co-founder Steve Koepp (photo by From Day One)Murphy presented the idea to her new mentor, asking what if mindset is more than just internal? What if it’s baked into culture and influences the cultivation of talent? She blinked a few times and said, “No one's ever thought of mindset this way. But we should do it together. And that began 15 years of work on reconceptualizing the mindset, as not just in our head, but also as this cultural feature.”Time to StudyNow with 75 studies in her back pocket, Murphy has seen firsthand just how deep mindset goes. Murphy and Dweck looked at the mindset of teachers and faculty members in K-12 and college and how they practice that in the classroom.“We look at how that impacts student experience. We’ve created apps that actually measure student experience in the moment looking at their sense of belonging, whether they think their teacher has a growth mindset, belief for them or not, their sense of self efficacy, their trust of the teacher.”What they found was that even if a student has a growth mindset, when set into a fixed mindset culture, they won’t have the opportunity to benefit from their growth mindset. The group trumps and stilts their progress.  In the National Study of Learning Mindsets, a randomized control trial of more than 12,000 students around the country underwent a growth mindset program to see how it would impact their grades and if they’d be willing to take challenging courses. As expected, it had a positive effect. Their GPA was higher and more of them enrolled in the challenging courses than the control group. They also looked at where the program didn’t work.“The answer was two places,” Murphy said. “It was with teachers that had more fixed mindset beliefs or engaged in fixed mindset practices, then giving students that personal growth mindset. The effect was zero. It had no impact. It wasn't even a small impact – it had no impact.”The other place it didn’t work was when peers didn’t engage in challenge seeking, then students were less likely to want to work hard. But when there were teachers and peers who relished a challenge and supported each other, the growth mindset helped students flourish.Organizational CultureWorking with companies of all shapes and sizes, Murphy saw similar results. The mindset of a team at large has a huge impact on creativity, collaboration, and innovation. In one study in particular, they looked at the difference between a psychologically safe environment and a growth minded environment. They found that psychological safety is the baseline for any other growth to take place.“Psychological safety just means that you're willing to speak up when something’s gone wrong. But growth mindset culture really is being vigilant about how to improve what you’re doing, your interactions with others, the outcomes and the strategies that you’re trying. You’re proactively looking for improvement opportunities.”In fixed mindset cultures, they search for the narrow genius prototype to come up with all the answers. When in reality, a growth culture would open up the spectrum of recruiting, looking more at positive values. As Murphy says, a growth culture helps organizations naturally look for more diversity. “What’s most important is the extent to which people are willing to develop, grow and learn.”Changing Company CultureIn her book, Murphy goes over four common mindset triggers which can help individuals understand where people are on the fixed to growth spectrum. In turn, those who work with those individuals can help them shift. For example, one trigger is praise. If someone else gets praise, how does the person react? Are they happy for them, or are they jealous, thinking they are less than? One way to help foster a growth mindset is how praise is given. Rather than a “good job!” which doesn’t offer helpful feedback, Murphy suggested managers repeat what the person has done so well, so they can replicate that and others can encourage.When Satya Nadella first came to Microsoft as CEO, he described Microsoft as everyone thinking about their own silo. He read Dweck’s book and wanted to help Microsoft become the first growth minded culture and company. Kathleen Hogan, head of talent, asked how things needed to change so they could recruit and onboard people that would help shift the company’s culture. She implemented changes, but success didn’t come right away. Some bragged they had the biggest growth mindset in the room. “She had to really talk to people about what a growth mindset actually looks like. And to bake that in to some of the incentive systems and also some of the mentoring and sponsoring and support systems so that people could take on challenges could make mistakes, and actually get points for the learning and the growth from those mistakes and the communicating of those mistakes across the company, so that the whole company can learn at the same time more rapidly.” That’s when things picked up. Slowly but surely, the culture was changing. It became okay to make mistakes, but putting out ideas and taking risks and being open to failure became the norm. And that’s how they got cloud computing. Was the culture change worth it? No doubt about it.Carrie Snider is a Phoenix-based journalist and marketing copywriter.

Carrie Snider | March 28, 2024

For Hourly Workers, Building a Culture That’s Motivating and Gratifying

Monigo Saygbay-Hallie, Ph.D., is the chief people officer at Checkers & Rally’s Drive-In Restaurants. She reflects that at 15, she cried on the first day of her first job at Mr. Jim’s Pizza due to stress because the telephone was ringing off the hook as a steady stream of customers called in their delivery orders.However, by her third month on the job, she was an assistant manager closing the restaurant by herself on Sundays. The woman who owned that Mr. Jim’s Pizza franchise “believed I had more potential than I thought I had,” she told moderator Lydia Dishman in a fireside chat at From Day One’s March virtual conference.“She gave me more responsibility each and every day. That’s what I love about the restaurant industry. They take chances on many people,” she said. Saygbay-Hallie would then go into HR because “I learned that I really love the human element of what drives businesses in developing and growing people and making them better leaders.”Motivating Hourly WorkersWhen it comes to motivating employees, managers should remember that “at the end of the day, everybody wants the same thing, whether you are frying fries at the grill or developing a marketing strategy,” she said. “You want to be heard and valued, and you want an opportunity to grow.”In the back of the house of a Checkers and Rally’s restaurant, “we have huddle meetings every day where we talk about how we’ve made sales,” Saygbay-Hallie said. “It’s like, ‘Great job, thank you.’ It’s high-fives.”The company’s IT team sends an email every week to the manager of each restaurant to let them know which employees at that store have upcoming birthdays or anniversaries. The email also offers ideas on how to celebrate the milestone, such as cupcakes.A Sense of BelongingWhen workers feel like they belong, “they put that extra effort in, that extra love in your food,” Saygbay-Hallie said.Lydia Dishman interviewed Monigo Saygbay-Hallie of Checkers & Rally's during the fireside chat (photo by From Day One)Checkers and Rally’s does a quarterly survey, asking employees if they feel like they belong, if they appreciate their supervisor, and if their supervisor appreciates them.“That measures our culture,” Saygbay-Hallie said. “And from that survey, we then go back and develop action plans, talking with each of the employees about what we can do more or less in order to make this a place where they want to stay.”Communication is KeyMost of Checkers and Rally’s management hires are internal promotions, “so they were once a team member in that very store,” Saygbay-Hallie said.These fledgling managers need to learn how to communicate with the employees they are now supervising, she said. For example, they must be able to instruct team members on how to do their jobs and have conversations with them about their performance. Therefore, Checkers and Rally’s created the Leadership of the Future program, which teaches all these skills.One thing Checkers and Rally’s teaches its managers is how to recognize when a team member might be struggling with something in their personal life that is affecting their job performance.“You want to have grace, but you also want to have standards,” she said. “So, it’s really communicating if you see someone come in late constantly, or if they’re not giving their best effort, it’s a one-on-one conversation.” This allows managers the opportunity to offer support rather than blaming the employee.Encouraging Career DevelopmentShift managers and assistant managers at Checkers and Rally’s restaurants do quarterly check-ins with their team. Saygbay-Hallie says 75% of those discussions are about employee performance, while 25% is centered on career development.“In my visits to the restaurants, I’ve talked to women, in the spirit of Women’s History Month, about them moving on to be a keyholder, where they're a general manager,” Saygbay-Hallie said.Some hourly employees who speak English as a second language say they don’t think they have the English skills to communicate as a manager, she said. That’s why Checkers and Rally’s offers free language classes.“We don’t want any barriers to anyone,” Saygbay-Hallie said.Mary Pieper is a freelance writer based in Mason City, Iowa.

Mary Pieper | March 26, 2024

The Keys to Employee Engagement in Today’s Workplace

A positive company culture can power strong engagement with employees, with business yielding benefits like higher productivity and profitability. As senior director of talent management and organizational effectiveness at The Home Depot, Joe Garcia knew the secret to strong employee engagement came with finding the right employees first.“When we start to go deep into trying to understand what drives engagement, we often think about the environment, the effectiveness of leaders, and the work-life balance,” Garcia said. “But we don't always spend a ton of time thinking if we are selecting folks that are likely to be a good fit for the role and the culture of the company.”With approximately 475,000 associates, Garcia discovered his high-performing associates had distinguishable qualities such as having a high desire to help others and openness to learning.“That propensity and desire to learn was a big predictor of success so we built assessments and structured interview guides with questions that are attempting to measure not only your experience but also your culture fit with clear anchors,” said Garcia.At From Day One’s March virtual conference, Garcia and a panel of other leaders joined Lydia Dishman, senior editor of growth and engagement at Fast Company, in a discussion on how to effectively drive employee engagement in today’s workplace.Providing Employees with Learning OpportunitiesWith a remote workforce, vice president of human resources and recruiting at Allied Universal Security Services, Kimberly Ardo-Eisenbeis knew she would have to find creative strategies to engage her employees.After trial-and-error of different strategies, Ardo-Eisenbeis found offering small micro-learning opportunities was the sweet spot for her employees.“We have an amazing talent and development team that puts together these small micro-learnings that are five to ten minutes long. These nuggets are meaningful and can help engage our employees because these are not just checking-the-box learning, but information that somebody can then act on,” Ardo-Eisenbeis said.For Ardo-Eisenbeis, the key was to value the quality of engagement over quantity. “Rather than sitting someone in a classroom or having virtual learnings where there’s not much appetite, we learned that these small micro-learnings can still fill the bucket,” Ardo-Eisenbeis said. “When it comes to learning, it’s not always about quantity but about the quality and the intention, and what somebody can do with that information.”The group of leaders spoke on a panel during From Day One's March virtual conference about energizing workers (photo by From Day One)Learning and development can also be powerful drivers in employee engagement, with 80% of employees reporting that learning and development opportunities would help them feel more engaged at work.Wielding learning as a form of engagement can also help benefit other areas of the business, Shawn Overcast, chief insights officer of Explorance said.“Learning matters as a driver of engagement and career development. Not only does learning aim to help us build skills and help to inform somebody's career development, but it also allows us to listen,” Overcast said. “As we formally bring people together and ask them questions about their experience, [learning] acts as a listening hub and an opportunity to network which can support functional collaboration, relationship building, and further build trust and psychological safety in the organization.”Charting Different Career PathsThe shift from traditional linear career paths to non-linear paths is increasingly more common, with 52% of U.S. workers having considered a job change, and as many as 44% having actual plans to make the change last year. The finding is in line with what commercial real estate company, Unibail-Rodamco-Westfield, currently is seeing.“We lean into internal mobility and allow people to move from one function to an entirely different one. So, we’ve seen big bold moves, like people moving from finance to IT or people moving from marketing to sales,” Isobel Lincoln, senior vice president of human resources, said.Allowing workers to explore different career paths can prove beneficial to companies as it allows employees to continue to grow and learn new skill sets while remaining at a single organization. Workers who have moved internally have a 64% chance of remaining with an organization after three years, according to LinkedIn data. In contrast, only 45% of employees who haven’t moved internally have a smaller likelihood of staying with the company after three years.Lincoln already sees the benefits of internal mobility in her company. “More than half of my HR team have come from other parts of the business so it's working for us because we get to retain those employees for much longer.”Wanly Chen is a writer and poet based in New York City.

Wanly Chen | March 26, 2024