What Happens When Corporate Culture Has to Change

BY Angelica Frey | September 29, 2020

For many companies, this era of multiple crises has focused attention on the strengths and weaknesses of their mission, their values and other fundamentals. A strong corporate culture, as robust as it might be, is useless if it does not adapt. Adaptable companies, on average, bring in 15% more in annual revenue than those in the same industry with a more rigid corporate culture, a University of California, Berkeley, research paper reported. How does a corporate mission like PepsiCo’s, which is “Create more smiles with every sip and bite,” look like in 2020? And with everyone talking about the importance of empathy in Corporate America, what does that really mean?

“When Corporate Culture Needs to Evolve,” was the topic of a panel discussion among corporate leaders at From Day One’s September virtual conference, which focused on managing change. For many leaders, the multiple crises of 2020 brought dramatic shifts in their roles in support of their employer’s culture, they told moderator Lydia Dishman, an editor and writer for Fast Company. “It was supposed to be a big year for my department,” said Christine Salerno, the global head of social impact for Marsh & McLennan, who had created the department a decade ago. “It’s really all about engaging our employees, inspiring them to give back to their communities,” she said. After the pandemic struck, however, Salerno’s team pivoted to focus on disaster relief for the company’s employees, creating a COVID-19 support fund that has granted more than $2.5 million to thousands of company workers affected by the pandemic. The company’s CEO, Salerno said, felt it was important to make a statement that “we are a people-first company.”

The speakers on From Day One's panel on corporate culture at the September virtual conference (Image by From Day One)

A people-first approach calls for a culture of communication. “Rather than having business calls [some teams have] have calls just to talk, just for people to express themselves and say what they're feeling,” said Randy Martinez, director of strategic diversity management at CVS Health. “And we're seeing people latch on to certain leaders and reach out and say, Hey, do you mind if we spend some time talking about this? And I do it.” Curtis Stancil, an HR business partner director at Sodexo, the global food-service company, said this communication is particularly crucial in companies that have made layoffs or furloughs. “With the current state of affairs we have to not only keep our employees that are remaining engaged but optimistic about the future and [about] how we can still have growth opportunities and still benefit those that we're serving, even under this dire situation,” Stancil said.

Several months into the pandemic, with the killing of George Floyd in police hands, corporate leaders needed to respond not just to a health crisis but a surge of expectation that they should be addressing social injustice as well. In the first phase of the pandemic, CVS focused on setting up testing sites in underserved communities. But after Floyd’s death and the ensuing protests, the company’s approach to systemic inequity became broader. “Suddenly we found ourselves investing $600 million, but to address inequality faced by Black people in disenfranchised communities,” said Martinez. “And we find ourselves now right in the middle of the conversation and culture shaping conversation for the company. Our purpose is to put people on a path to better health.” CVS employees then take the conversations into their own hands. “There are book clubs that are starting inside the company, based on the social injustice issues that we're dealing with, so it's creating a conversation. And then from that people are breaking off into one-on-one discussions,” he said.

At Even, a responsible earned wage access (EWA) provider that helps employees plan their finances, the surge in concern about social justice spurred the company’s co-founder Jon Schlossberg to refocus Even’s commitment to the issue. “As the CEO of the company, I have the pleasure and the responsibility of being able to set the company's objectives,” said Schlossberg. “And one of the first things I did is put together a task force to create a company-level objective for the company to be anti-racist, and more inclusive. And make that objective equivalent to our business objectives. Because I believe we have to show our clients that we walk this walk. But also, I think everyone is well aware of all of the research, which shows a more inclusive and  diverse workforce is going to lead to better business results.”

The role of the manager is crucial in shaping company culture. “For me, when it comes to learning, mentorship or sponsorship, during this time it has been absolutely critical that we defined what the role of the manager is now,” said Rosa Santos, a VP of talent management and organization development at PepsiCo. Companies can have “very specific leadership frameworks and models,” she said, “but when it comes to actual leading through these tumultuous times they get completely shaken up,” she said. Her company responded by reframing the directions. “So we define specific meanings or expectations that are very basic for our managers. I specifically said, You need to be a source of optimism and stability for employees. You really need to stay connected and engaged at this moment in time, you really need to lead by example.”

Yet this does not just have to do with mere output and performance. Schlossberg wants to get rid of the ideal of bringing one’s “best self” to a work environment, the idea of hyper-optimizing one’s potential. For a lot of employees, it can mean repressing the rest of their lives. “Tons and tons of people can't even bring their whole selves,” said Schlossberg. “They have to put on a show for the people that they're surrounded by at work,” he said. “[Now, during the pandemic] you can see more of people's whole selves because oftentimes your video is in their living room with them. So, really, our approach has been, what work do we need to do to understand people's lives, their whole selves?”

Angelica Frey is a writer and a translator based in Milan and Brooklyn.


RELATED STORIES

DEI Will Endure, But Corporate Advocates Will Need to Reframe Their Approach

The recent headlines say it all:“Inside the anti-DEI crusade” (The New York Times)“DEI efforts are under siege” (CNN)“DEI is under attack” (Harvard Business Review)With initiatives toward diversity, equity, and inclusion enduring a backlash on several fronts, advocates would be well-advised to rethink their goals, strategies, and messaging. If there’s still a strong business and moral case for DEI, what approaches will work better in the current climate of culture wars, corporate austerity, and legal challenges? Experts on a panel at From Day One’s February virtual conference discussed the path forward.While the headlines make the struggle seem dire, panelist Sue Schmidlkofer, global director of diversity and inclusion at UPS, says not to be alarmed. “There are cycles to this kind of work,” she said. “It’s not going away, and it’s part of the foundation for organizations large and small.” Much of the controversy, she says, comes down to the proper framing and education about the initiatives.William Rolack, chief inclusion & diversity officer for management at Kroll, agrees that the added scrutiny around DEI comes down to a lack of understanding or “misplacement” of its role within the broader corporate conversation. “DEI is not a policy. It is a philosophy,” he said. “We influence policy for equity. We don’t write policy.”“There has been an ebb and flow for DEI, as a term, and certainly as a perceived discipline. In many cases, it's been politicized and weaponized,” agreed Lauren Guthrie, VP of global talent and inclusion, diversity, equity at VF Corporation. “But I personally believe that it is an essential set of concepts, skills, and capabilities that are necessary in our culture for an organization to be successful.”Taking a Global Perspective“We are a consumer-serving organization. And for us to do that work effectively and authentically, and to connect with our consumers around the world, we have to embrace and uphold the tenets of what it means to serve those who are different than ourselves,” Guthrie said. Her organization upholds “integrity, growth mindset, and consumer centricity” as three of its core company values. This infuses the philosophy of DEI into every level of the business – from hiring and establishing a leadership competency model to building an environment of psychological safety for employees, decision-making, consumer support, and beyond.Schmidlkofer says that UPS’s DEI initiatives grew from the company’s global reach, dating back to the 1960s as the company began to reach outside of the United States to what is now over 220 countries and territories. “You're going to reflect the fabric of those communities,” she said.The group of DEI leaders discussed the topic “DEI Will Endure, But Corporate Advocates Will Need to Reframe Their Approach” during the virtual conference (photo by From Day One) “I love how you say, ‘We need to look like our customers.’ I think that will embed diversity into your efforts automatically,” said moderator Nicole Smith, editorial audience director at Harvard Business Review. Having DEI ingrained into the company’s culture allows UPS to operate from a position of strength, she says, so that any new initiatives become a natural extension of its past track record and don’t seem performative.This long term commitment to inclusion can feel more natural and nuanced to potential critics. Gus Viano, VP of global diversity, equity & inclusion at Brink's, says that organizations that only started DEI departments as a response to the murder of George Floyd and the subsequent Black Lives Matter movement, face far more pushback than those that have been incorporating it into strategy for much longer.DEI in Your Business StrategyFor Brink’s, Viano says, DEI is tied to ESG (environmental, social, and governance). “We have to report it to investors as part of our sustainability report,” he said. Guthrie agrees that DEI can have “dollar and cent impact” that can make it easier to make the case for its importance within an organization.“We’re looking to maximize not only the productivity of our workforce, but their ability to live the corporate values in an authentic way,” she said, which in turn can impact benchmarks like retention, attrition, and engagement. Rolack warns that sometimes corporations can get so caught up in compliance and education on DEI, that they miss the economic value, “the understanding that everything that DEI touches has a financial formula.”Looking at consumers from a DEI perspective can also expand customer reach and therefore increase profits. Guthrie notes that inclusive philosophy can come through in marketing efforts, product websites, and advocacy initiatives. “We’re always thinking about this holistically through the lens of associate, consumer, and community. And through each one of those filters, there is a set of metrics that we can use to hold ourselves accountable, and also demonstrate a very palpable return on investment for the work that we're doing in this space,” she said.Mitigating the “Threat Level”Viano emphasized the importance of collaborating with the legal department to ensure that any statements or policies are just and defensible. Schmidlkofer encourages all organizations to do a legal audit of their current DEI practices, especially in the wake of the recent Supreme Court ruling on affirmative action, to ensure they are still being intentional as well as legally compliant.Schmidlkofer also reiterates the need for better awareness about what DEI really means to help decrease the feelings of threat and anxiety around the issue – and making it not just about race, gender, and compulsory unconscious bias training. “We all know how terrible it feels to be excluded. So let’s focus more on bringing people together so that the business performs better,” she said. These “courageous conversations,” as she calls them, take time and patience.When DEI is under attack, employees from diverse groups may feel under attack by extension. “I advise the leaders of the company to speak openly about it, and to be very specific about the position of the company as it supports diversity and inclusion, making sure that employees not only feel safer and that there is a sense of sustainability with regard to the DEI, but also that leaders are committed to the work,” Viano said.Incorporating DEI into employee systems also means ensuring people are not excluded, which can lead to resentment and the feeling of being under threat. “White males are sometimes left out of systems that may only have [identity-based] employee networks, but may not have an intersectionality network,” Rolack said. This nuanced approach to inclusion is crucial to cultivating allyship.Moving the Work ForwardEstablishing DEI as a philosophy that all employees feel ownership over is key to moving the dial forward. It starts with leadership embedding the philosophy, and then creating accountabilities for other employees too. “It needs to have a clear functional owner within the construct of the organization to drive that work,” Guthrie said.“Through programs, processes, and ways of working, the evidence needs to be palpable. Getting tactical about the clear actions, which then can allow an organization to speak transparently about progress or lack thereof, is really where the ownership lies.” Crucially, organizations must choose a path that makes the most sense for its own structure and needs. “There’s so much opportunity to lean into this platform in an authentic and an effective way for your organization.”Katie Chambers is a freelance writer and award-winning communications executive with a lifelong commitment to supporting artists and advocating for inclusion. Her work has been seen in HuffPost, Honeysuckle Magazine, and several printed essay collections, among others, and she has appeared on Cheddar News, iWomanTV, and CBS New York.

Katie Chambers | March 04, 2024

Taking the Long View Toward Progress in Workplace Diversity

“Things get hard when they’re working, but that doesn’t mean we let up,” said Loren Hudson, senior vice president and chief diversity officer of Comcast Cable. “Right now is our time to remain committed to supporting our teammates and communities because we have all learned that DEI is a key part of how we win talent, business space, and how we make an impact in the communities where we live and work.” DEI initiatives across the country are being politically scrutinized, resulting in bans and rollbacks in colleges and companies. Yet in the midst of it all, Hudson remains steadfast in her stance in supporting DEI.In a fireside chat at From Day One’s February virtual conference, with Sharon Epperson, senior personal finance correspondent at CNBC, NBCUniversal, Hudson discussed the current world of DEI and how companies can maintain their progress in driving change.Placing DEI at the CoreA CNBC survey found that nearly 80% of survey respondents wanted to work for a company that valued DEI issues, showing the importance of DEI to employees and job seekers alike.DEI initiatives extend far beyond just the workplace, Hudson said. “[DEI] touches so many aspects of our lives, from personal to professional, to our business to our community,” Hudson said. “At the heart of what is important, DEI practices, initiatives, mindset and focus are good for the business, people leadership, employee experience, and community activism.”Leaders can often assess the success of DEI initiatives and programs against business value and employee experience, Hudson says. However, leaders who lead DEI initiatives with intentionality can be more fruitful in the long term.“When I look at businesses who are focusing intentionally on this space, their most senior leaders have said, “This is important to us as leaders, as a business and as a community partner,” Hudson said. “Many organizations that can say that they were successful in this space are because it connects back to what the organization stands for.”Driving Equity Beyond the WorkplaceDuring the pandemic, Hudson realized there was a sudden need for internet access by community members who traditionally did not have regular access.Sharon Epperson, right, interviewed Loren Hudson, left, at From Day One's February virtual conference on the topic of Getting to the Next Stage of Diversity and Belonging (photo by From Day One)As a leader of a telecommunications company, Hudson knew her role was more than just driving change and equity in the workplace, it also meant driving change in the communities they served.By partnering with community organizations, Hudson and her team at Comcast were able to provide free Wi-Fi centers and resources for the communities. “We provided broadband while other partners provided the site and lunch or breakfast,” Hudson said.The success of these sites wouldn’t have come together if community members hadn’t raised their concerns, Hudson says.“Without partners telling us what the people are whispering or loudly saying, we wouldn't necessarily know all of the things we may know,” Hudson said. “So, talking to partners who are closest to the community members is key because they provide us perspective and provide insights to what their community or their members are saying.”Embracing Outside PerspectivesBy encouraging a growth mindset for employees, leaders can help cultivate a more inclusive work environment. This can aid the progress of DEI as team members are more committed to learning and growing. To help foster a growth mindset in teams, Hudson recommends actively looking for outside perspectives.“I bring other CEOs and their teams in, and we share what we’re doing, what keeps us up at night, and what’s going well. We can play off each other and do joint things to have greater impact, and that’s important across whatever line of business we’re doing,” Hudson said. “It’s creating this space for new fresh perspectives by inviting people from different backgrounds to come in and share those perspectives. That’s how we learn and grow and innovate.”Wanly Chen is a writer and poet based in New York City.

Wanly Chen | February 29, 2024

Responding to Pushback and Creating More Inclusive Environments That Value Diversity

Even though diversity, equity, and inclusion in the workplace leads to better financial outcomes, greater social impact, and more satisfied employees, DEI efforts are “being used as part of the culture wars right now,” said Malia Lazu. Lazu, CEO of the Urban Labs at MIT and author of the book From Intention to Impact: A Practical Guide to Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion spoke in a fireside chat during From Day One’s February Virtual Conference. “It’s important for us to remember that DEI is not against the wall because it’s a failing endeavor. It’s against the wall because people are scared of losing what they think they have now,” Lazu told moderator Jeanhee Kim. “When you’re privileged, fairness feels like a step down.”Corporate leaders and managers must truly believe that “DEI is the platform of the future” if they are going to have the will to fight the inevitable pushback, Lazu said. Although political pressure can be intimidating, organizations can gain the courage to continue their DEI endeavors from realizing the pushback is coming from less than 25% of the U.S. population, says Lazu. “This isn’t about politics for you, this is about competing in a global economy. And in 20 years, this country is going to look very different.”Acknowledging the ProblemOrganizations first need to find their gaps in DEI before they can resolve them, says Lazu. And that realization can cause discomfort.Journalist Jeanhee Kim interviewed author Malia Lazu in a fireside chat titled “How to Respond to the Pushback to Create More Inclusive Environments That Honor and Value Diversity” (photo by From Day One)“I often tell my clients if we’re not uncomfortable, we haven’t started working yet,” Lazu said. It’s important to understand that racism isn’t just an interpersonal problem but systemic one, said Lazu. “It exists whether you’re a nice person or not,” she said, noting that in American school’s, children are taught about Manifest Destiny rather than other philosophies that don’t center the white European perspective. Once people understand that institutional racism exists and what causes it, “then we can start deconstructing it,” Lazu said. The Role of Middle Management and HR A top-down approach to DEI won’t make the changes that are needed in the company, according to Lazu. “Where the change gets lost is in middle management,” she said. Middle managers and HR officers can do a lot to create a positive environment for DEI within their companies because “modeling behavior is critically important,” Lazu said. If these individuals aren’t fully invested in DEI and are worried that the company will be getting less qualified employees by hiring more women, for example, they need to learn more about what DEI really means and become more confident with it, says Lazu. Middle managers and HR leaders also need to recognize their power to make changes, whether it’s making sure they are selecting a diverse slate of candidates or even just deciding where to buy coffee from, Lazu says.It’s OK to Make Mistakes While LearningEven those with the best of intentions can make mistakes when it comes to DEI efforts. Lazu says she learned this first-hand when she was helping to organize the first disability fashion show in New England. “It became front and center how ableist I was because I had never been blessed enough to organize with people with disabilities,” she said. “And I couldn’t just walk away from it and say, ‘Oh, well.’”Instead, Lazu asked the disability community, “How do I come back from using the word ‘normal’ when I meant ‘able-bodied’?”“It’s about understanding that if you’re going to do this authentically, like any other relationship, you’re going to step on toes,” she said. “Anyone who has life partners knows, even they will get it wrong sometimes.”That’s why it’s important that companies have a culture of “generosity of interpretation. It’s important to understand that someone tried and missed the mark, and have a reparative practice.” Mary Pieper is a freelancer reporter based in Mason City, Iowa.

Mary Pieper | February 26, 2024