How to Make Your Recruiting Metrics More Transparent

BY Emily Nonko | February 11, 2021

Company recruiting metrics were once fairly simple. They consisted of reactive data that measured such factors as the time to hire, the cost per hire, and the number of hires made in a given period. This was considered a one-size-fits-all approach for companies across the board.

The problem is, those metrics didn’t really work. They never told a company the full story when it came to recruiting productivity and the impact of recruiting on the company’s bottom line. With better technology, however, “we’re now able to provide more strategic results and reports that are directly linked to better outcomes,” says Viet Nguyen, head of customer talent advisory for the talent-acquisition company Gem. “Recruiting is no longer a tactical and reactive function, it becomes a strategic arm of the business.”

In a presentation at From Day One’s virtual conference on acquiring skilled talent in the year ahead, Nguyen spoke about which recruiting metrics matter to whom–and how often you should be reporting them. He laid out just how granular these metrics should get and how those details can pay off for the overall company.

To make the transition toward strategic reporting, Nguyen suggested that companies shouldn’t get hung up on the past. “This is a trap that’s easy to fall into with reporting,” he noted. “What you really want to do is use historical data to predict the future.” Recruitment leaders should also know their organizational goals from the get-go, be prepared to make internal comparisons, and report on the why, not the what. “It’s a step toward solving the problem as opposed to reporting on the what, which isn’t nearly as productive as you could be,” said Nguyen.

As far as what metrics are most helpful for C-level leadership, Nguyen highlighted the business impacts of recruiting–“how it affects revenue, productivity and innovation”–as well as the importance of full transparency around metrics that impact business results. He added that leadership should leave space for additional comments, ideas or changes. “The last metric should be what’s top of mind for [the C-level] in that moment,” Nguyen said.

One report that company leaders should consider is the time to fill a position and how you’re pacing against it. “This report gives executives an idea of how recruiting is tracking against the original plan,” according to Nguyen. The longer a role stays open, the more likely it is to negatively affect that area of the business. “So having an idea of when goals can be filled is incredibly important to allow the rest of the business to forecast effectively,” he said.

Viet Nguyen, head of customer talent advisory for the recruiting platform Gem (Photo courtesy of Gem)

Another potential report is “cost of vacancy,” which is the payroll-and benefit-savings minus revenue lost to a vacant role. “Simply put, it's the cost of a role remaining open longer than intended,” Nguyen said. This metric should be tracked over time; it will help demonstrate how recruiting impacts the bottom line of the business, as it can be tied back to revenue.

Nguyen delved deep into the topic of diversity, suggesting that companies set realistic diversity hiring goals, figure out what diversity goals look like “at the top of the funnel,” and commit to long-term investments in diversity over short-term fixes.

He shared a highly-detailed report that tracked applicants' race and gender alongside metrics like when they submitted their application, if they had phone or onsite interviews, and if an offer was extended. “Diversity is something that's top of mind for executives, so they'll want to get into the details,” he noted.

Nguyen focused sharply on pass-through rates, which he called “the single best metric recruiters have to debug a pipeline.” He added, “the pass-through rates will make it abundantly clear where there's a problem in the interview process, interviewer quality, candidate quality, or a combination of the three.” In this case there’s no single metric to put into use; ideally companies need to set specific goals and mentor team members on how to read pass-through data.

A “source of hire” report is simpler but still a valuable asset. “Looking at this report will tell you which sources are providing the highest volume and the highest quality of candidates,” said Nguyen. “By understanding these two metrics, recruiters and sourcers will know which channels yield the highest ROI for their time.”

Finally, a capacity report will tell hiring managers how many total hours their team needs to dedicate to interviewing in order to hit hiring targets. “Every hour their team spends interviewing is an hour they're not spending on their primary business responsibilities,” said Nguyen. He suggested this report utilize historical data from the company, set the total hours expected of a hiring team, and allow the hiring manager to distribute hours across their team.

Understanding how much time a hiring team spends on interviewing should translate into improved candidate experience. Companies can bolster recruitment data with candidate-experience surveys and by asking for—and recording—rejection reasons.

Only 25% of companies make recruiting data available to their entire recruiting team. Fully 70% of hiring managers believe their recruiting organizations need to be more data-driven. These data points show there are lots of missed opportunities in fostering a transparent, data-driven recruiting culture that’s deeply connected to the company’s business goals. As Nguyen summarized: “Anchor your reporting to position recruiting as a strategic partner.”

Editor's note: From Day One thanks our partner who sponsored this thought-leadership spotlight, Gem. Please visit our conference page to register for more upcoming events.

Emily Nonko is a Brooklyn, NY-based reporter who writes about real estate, architecture, urbanism and design. Her work has appeared in the Wall Street Journal, New York magazine, Curbed and other publications.


RELATED STORIES

Sleep Care Done Right: Transform Employee Health and Lower Total Cost of Healthcare

Increasing healthcare costs and the rising burden of chronic conditions are projected to increase by 6% in 2024 compared to 2023. Interestingly, some of the most expensive chronic conditions are closely associated with sleep disorders. In a recent From Day One webinar, experts from Nox Health discussed how companies can enhance the overall health of their workforce by promoting sleep care.In this post-Covid workplace, the complexity of roles has increased, driven by an accelerating prevalence of concerns around behavioral and mental health. The general consensus, says Steve Cohan, EVP of commercial markets at Nox Health, is that we’re all facing a general kind of point solution fatigue.So, how do organizations improve the overall coordination of care? Promoting sleep care “as a kind of a soft approach to a very hard issue,” is part of the solution, says Cohan. “Sleep is the golden chain that binds health and our bodies together,” he says, citing a quote from English dramatist Thomas Decker.“If you look at the totality, about 50 to 70 million Americans actually have a chronic sleep-wake disorder,” Dr. Jason Ong, behavioral sleep medicine director shares.The most common disorder is obstructive sleep apnea (OSA), a condition where there are pauses in your breathing that cause a sleep disruption. This causes people to generally be very, very sleepy or fatigued during the day, he says.Chronic insomnia is another prevalent sleep disorder. It covers trouble falling asleep, trouble staying asleep, and even waking up too early and not being able to get the full amount of sleep.Another common sleep condition is restless leg syndrome, a neuromuscular sleep disorder characterized by discomfort and a need to get up and move around. Circadian rhythm sleep-wake disorders are also common. This is where there is a misalignment between your body's natural clock and the time when you're trying to sleep or trying to be awake.Dr. Jason Ong spoke during the webinar about sleep care (company photo)So, how do sleep disorders affect other chronic health conditions? And what are the consequences when you have one of these leading disorders? According to Dr. Ong, when you have sleep disruption, it affects the body and the systems within the body. With sleep apnea, for example, the body can suffer from elevated levels of cortisol and blood sugar, creating a cascade of reactions like heightened heart rate, blood pressure, and insulin levels, among others.“So if you take a look at all these things that happen when our sleep is disrupted, it affects hormones, it affects cardiovascular systems, [and] metabolic systems,” said Dr. Ong. “And so you can see how all together this can really exacerbate chronic diseases such as hypertension, diabetes, heart disease, and stroke.”Many healthcare members with sleep disorders cost double that of the average member, while members with two or more chronic conditions cost 46% of total healthcare costs. And yet, sleep-related costs account for less than 1% of total healthcare spending. So what can be done?Cohan advocates for a whole-person approach. As people enter into a solution, the provider takes total ownership of the patient experience throughout all iterative steps from education, evaluation, testing, diagnosis, and then, importantly, value care.The patient is then only billed once they have a diagnosis.“So all of those iterative steps around making people aware, going through a very detailed evaluation, testing and diagnosis, including interaction with our sleep care specialists,” Cohan said. “Those all occur at no expense to the patient, no expense to the plan sponsor, only if the patient agrees to go on therapy, and then continues on therapy, is their billing incurred.”At the moment, there are certain barriers to members adhering to and persisting with their treatment, says Jennifer Lindskoog, Nox’s SVP of client success. The first is a lack of understanding that they may have a sleep disorder.  Second, upon diagnosis, the processes are typically uncoordinated and unsupported by an underlying clinically integrated care approach, leading to limited adoption of care.For Nox Health, holistic care encompasses working with clients to build out an entire awareness campaign that’s not just dependent on a physician or on-site clinic referral.This also includes an easily accessible app that includes a simple 13-question checkup that enables a member to understand the duration, timing and quality of their sleep. From here, members with potential sleeping disorders are automatically made eligible for medical intervention through their health plan. The system will then pop up a schedule of appointments with a board-certified sleep physician, only for their area and the times available.This ensures the patient does not have to scroll through a list of physician appointments that may not even be for their area. From that physician's appointment, which is a visual telehealth appointment, the patient is often then recommended for a home-based sleep test with a very small kit that includes a device for diagnosing sleep apnea, insomnia, or restless leg syndrome.After this comes an interpretation and appointment with the patient with a clinician to explain the results of the sleep testing, along with the recommended treatment plan. The result is an end-to-end solution that makes sure patients are supported from the initial diagnosis to treatment, promoting better sleep care and overall health.Editor’s note: From Day One thanks our partner, Nox Health, for sponsoring this webinar. Keren's love for words saw her transition from a corporate employee into a freelance writer during the pandemic. When she is not at her desk whipping up compelling narratives and sipping on endless cups of coffee, you can find her curled up with a book, playing with her dog, or pottering about in the garden.

Keren Dinkin | March 26, 2024

Navigating the AI Revolution: Transforming Workforces for the Future

"What we’re going to do is talk through the impact of probably the two scariest letters when it comes to thinking about workforce and transformation: AI. But specifically the impact of these new tools on your workforce," said Akhil Chauhan, senior solution consultant at Orgvue. Chauhan spoke in a thought leadership spotlight at From Day One’s Houston event. Chauhan spoke about how Orgvue helps organizations strategize, prepare, and move towards an AI future.When people think of automation, they generally have robotics in mind – the sort of technology that can automate physical tasks. But the way society is now thinking about automation is more in terms of knowledge work. Chauhan cited research from Goldman Sachs indicating that 25% of the tasks people do today are at risk of automation in the near future.“What this tells us is that even though a large number of roles and a large portion of the workforce are going to be affected in some way, it’s actually more likely that small portions of people's day-to-day roles are going to be affected,” Chauhan said. Strategizing For a More Automated FutureThe key to success for any organization that isn’t already looking into these changes, would be to identify where that 25% is, then start building out resiliency from there, says Chauhan. This change, though, isn’t just affecting any one team at an organization, or a professional field, it impacts “everything from office and admin to legal.”"We’re seeing this as a transformational change across a broad range of your organizations. And that’s good news." Chauhan says companies that can adapt quickly will "see an uptick in productivity uptick in economic output.” Others that can’t adapt quickly, however, will be left behind.Chauhan laid out ways to prepare an organization’s workforce for the impact of AI.First is benchmarking, or mapping existing benchmarks to your own data to determine the impact of AI on your organization. To create a benchmark, you would look at similar roles across the industry and look at skill sets, salary, and other attributes.“There’s loads of different benchmarks that are available. Some focus more on roles, others focus on skills or industry. But there's a lot of information that can give you a very quick insight into what the impact of automation is on your workforce.”Not all similar benchmarks, like engineers for example, are going to be the same across the board. “A software engineer at Lyondell is going to be very different from a software engineer at Southwest Airlines, which may again be quite different from a role defined in a generic benchmark,” Chauhan said. Akhil Chauhan, Senior Solution Consultant at Orgvue led the thought leadership spotlight in Houston Another way is by organization modeling, or modeling your future organization based on work that will be affected by AI. Chauhan says that if you know what role might be needed more in the future (and less of), then you can “build out team structures that can account for that type of change, and build out the different operating models aligned to different processes and technologies that those teams might be using.”Another is finding skills gaps, or understanding the skills you have today, which will be most impacted by AI, and the gap between the two. You might “have a look at the different skills that we need in the workforce today. What might be less prevalent tomorrow. And then how do we adapt our workforce through re-skilling and upskilling programs to make sure that we have a resilient workforce in the future," Chauhan added.None of these areas of preparation are prerequisites or contingent on one another. They might be complimentary but every organization has their own jumping off point, he says.  Guiding PrinciplesTo achieve any sort of success with these models, Chauhan offers some guiding principles: rapid assessment, detailed analysis, and design and implementation.First, you have to have good data. Consolidation of data and keeping it up to date will also help the organization make better informed decisions. “We know that data is messy, it sets in all sorts of different places, and is never going to be 100% accurate,” Chauhan said.Not every organization goes through all the pillars. Some stop at the assessment and use it as a starting point to start driving some organizational change. Others want to go deeper.This is where they might go into a detailed analysis, where Orgvue looks at the activities and work being performed by people in an organization to better understand how it can adapt to future change. It might also seek to identify who already has an AI skill set, what the future needs are, and where the skill gaps might be.The final principle is the design and implementation stage, where you use all the data you’ve gathered in the rapid assessment and the detailed analysis to design future scenarios. At this stage you want to understand the impacts of AI on headcount, cost, and team composition. This is a proactive capability around your organization so that it can adapt to all different kinds of changes."We can get all of these things together to then build that future state organization that keeps in mind the current state of the workforce, but also gives you a transition plan into a future state.”Editor’s note: From Day One thanks our partner, Orgvue, for sponsoring this thought leadership spotlight.Matthew Koheler is a freelance journalist and licensed real estate agent based in Washington, DC. His work has appeared in Greater Greater Washington, The Washington Post, The Southwester, and Walking Cinema, among others.

Matthew Koehler | March 25, 2024

How to Respond to the Day-to-Day Financial Stressors of Your Workforce

A unexpected car repair. A large medical bill. A broken furnace. For millions of American workers, these kinds of sudden expenses can be hard to handle—if not impossible. As major expenses like housing, education, and medical care increase, 59% of workers report that their compensation isn’t keeping up with the rising cost of living, according to PwC’s 2023 Employee Financial Wellness Survey; nearly half find it tough to cover household bills every month.“The cost of living has increased at a greater rate than wages for decades,” said Rachel Schneider, founder of CEO of Canary, a company that enables employers to offer emergency-relief grants. “So there’s a real need for financial solutions that help people to manage that.” In a From Day One Webinar, “How to Respond to the Day-to-Day Financial Stressors of Your Workforce,” Schneider spoke about the financial pressures workers face, how money stress can seep into the workplace, and what employers can do to help.Prior to founding Canary, Schneider spent years researching the finances of ordinary Americans and co-authored The Financial Diaries: How American Families Cope in a World of Uncertainty. “That really informed the work that I do today at Canary,” she said, “because for so many people, what we saw was this story of volatility.” Many of the families she spoke to made enough to get by—until there was a disruption. And then what?With little or no emergency savings, workers may resort to high-rate borrowing or retirement-account withdrawals, or simply go without a car or forgo needed medical care. And they don’t leave their troubles at home. “Employers are losing $4.7 billion in productivity every week because of the financial stress that workers are bringing to work,” Schneider said. If the lack of a car means the employee quits, that’s another cost. “We know that, at a minimum, it’s $7,000 to replace a person, even a fairly low-paid person,” Schneider said. “If I could have spent $2,000 to help this person fix their car instead, it’s a huge win for everybody.”By providing access to health insurance and retirement-savings plans, employers have already taken on an important role in their workers’ financial lives. Recognizing the financial pressures their employees can face, many supplement these benefits with programs to address financial wellness, including education and coaching. And thanks to a recent federal law allowing employers to automatically enroll workers in an emergency savings account tied to their retirement plan, more companies may add that benefit. Schneider encouraged employers to embrace a wide range of solutions: “There’s an incredible need for employers to keep the lens on what is the financial role they play with their workforce as broad as possible.”One way to do that is by providing employees facing an emergency with cash, something that can happen informally in an office via a GoFundMe campaign or more formally through a pay advance. A few companies have gone so far as to offer formal relief programs, such as Levi’s Red Tab Foundation. “Employers are responsive to this need because it's a basic human desire to help each other,” Schneider said.Journalist Ellen Stark interviewed Rachel Schneider of Canary during the recent webinar on responding to financial stressors (photo by From Day One)It was a recognition of that desire to help that led her to found Canary and make employee emergency grants more widely available. “A lot of people are really living at breakeven, without much cushion to save or to pay back a loan with interest,” Schneider said. “So I was looking for ways that we could efficiently get people additional money in that moment of crisis.” Emergency grant programs can be a major undertaking, involving establishing a nonprofit to disperse grants and a staff to administer them. “How do we make it possible for all employers to do it?”, Schneider recalled thinking.Canary makes it possible by handling all aspects of the program. Once employers fund a nonprofit relief fund, employees experiencing a financial hardship can apply for small grants online (employers set the maximum size) and submit required documentation. Canary reviews the application and disperses the money, often within days, allowing the worker’s need to remain confidential within the office. The grants—most commonly related to a car or healthcare—are not considered taxable income for the worker.Of course, a one-time grant may not solve an employee’s financial fragility, so Schneider encourages companies to consider grants as part of a larger financial wellness program, including education and advice. “I think that an emergency fund like ours is really most effective at a company that is thinking holistically about how it can help employees,” she said.Beyond helping individual workers get past a short-term crisis, this kind of program can have a deeper impact on the workplace, Schneider noted. “People on our platform who’ve received money say things like, my employer has proven that they walk the talk of our core values,” she said. That good will can spread further. Younger workers in particular want to feel a sense of purpose and care about the corporate brands they align themselves with. “The reality is that most of your workforce will not experience a crisis this year that causes them to apply,” Schneider said. “But everyone will know it exists and feel good about it. And that's really powerful.”Editor’s note: From Day One thanks our partner, Canary, who sponsored this thought leadership spotlight.Ellen Stark is an executive editor with Foundry 360 at Dotdash Meredith, where she creates relevant and engaging content for major financial services companies. Previously, she spent more than 20 years as a writer and editor at Money magazine and Money.com.(Featured illustration by Erhui1979/iStock by Getty Images) 

Ellen Stark | March 25, 2024