How to Succeed in the Remote Work Revolution

BY Sheila Flynn | April 25, 2021

Two and a half years before Covid-19 changed the world, Harvard professor Tsedal Neeley couldn’t have seen a global pandemic coming down the road. An expert in virtual and remote work, however, she did envision a massive shift to a non-office-based workforce. By the time coronavirus upended the global economy last year, she had already amassed 300 pages of material about the future trend for her book Remote Work Revolution: Succeeding from Anywhere, which was published last month.

Despite her research and expertise, though, even Neeley–who is the Naylor Fitzhugh Professor of Business Administration at Harvard Business School–did not expect some of the major and subtle effects of such a sudden switch to remote work across the globe. That shift, coupled with both its positive and negative ramifications, formed the basis of a conversation between Neeley and Adi Ignatius, editor-in-chief of Harvard Business Review, at From Day One’s virtual conference last week on “Digital Tools for Building an Engaged, Productive Team.”

Along with most corporate leaders, particularly in the tech industry, Neeley and Ignatius expressed doubts that workers will ever return to previous norms, with a hybrid workplace much more likely. But HR teams and executives from CEO level down must be prepared to shepherd that long-term transition with strong leadership, frequent reassessment, and open-mindedness, Neeley said. “I am 100% convinced that, if we do this hybrid right and with courage, and we set our policies based on need and not fear, we’re preparing for the digital revolution that’s right around the corner,” Neeley said.

That means identifying and addressing even minor personal and professional changes that have been highlighted by the massive shift in corporate culture over the past year–both good and bad, she added. “Commute times have disappeared, and people’s quality of life has gotten better [through] the democratization of interactions,” Neeley said. Among other equalizers, she pointed out that on video platforms like Zoom, everyone is the same height, using herself and her husband as examples (she’s 5-foot-4; he’s a foot taller).

Author Tsedal Neeley of Harvard Business School, left, in conversation with Adi Ignatius of Harvard Business Review. You can watch the video here.

“There is this democratization that takes place ... provided we have great leaders that give everyone an opportunity to speak. Operational costs have gone down; bloated travel budgets no longer seem necessary; hiring and retaining employees without asking them to move is actually a special thing that we’ve been seeing in Boston when it comes to identifying and attracting diverse candidates,” she said. “So it’s been great to see this untapped labor pool for many companies. Astronomical real estate no longer seems important ... The numbers are staggering when we look at how many people want to retain some form of remote work in their professional arrangements.”

Those are the upsides, yet there are unintended consequences too. Ignatius asked what kinds of obstacles exist when it comes to fostering a diverse, inclusive and collaborative environment when coworkers are so physically far apart–a question many employers are grappling with. “I consider this to be the diversity and digital era,” Neeley said. “And we need to work hard to create inclusive environments so you are working together. It’s a mindset shift; you may not think you’re working together, but you are–it’s just using digital tools.”

Employers need to be intentional about the impact of these tools on all the processes of bringing people together as a team, she said. “How we onboard people, how we integrate people, how we help them build social capital ... we had heard about the weak vs. strong ties. There’s a whole set of best practices when it comes to virtual onboarding. And we have to work hard to integrate people through the systems.”

She added: “We need to pair people with others so they feel like, ‘Ah, I actually can belong here.’ Experience the place through pairing, hiring, not just one Black person or Latinx member being lonely by themselves–imagine if we brought in two people instead.”

In confronting these issues, corporate leaders need to ask themselves if there are deeper-seated organizational issues contributing to isolation that have nothing to do with remoteness. “There are all sorts of strategies–effective strategies–that companies are using in order to ensure that people don’t experience professional isolation,” Neeley said. “It’s not the distribution ... it’s your existing culture and the lack of diversity. You know, diversity begets diversity.”

Neeley's new book, published last month

While remote work becomes more established, the inclusivity efforts must also take into account employees’ diverse living situations, mental health, and personal circumstances, she said. While a vast majority of employees prefer working from home, an estimated 15% hate it, she pointed out. On top of that, even workers who had been remote for long periods of time before the pandemic had to readjust, thrown off their rhythm when the rest of their colleagues essentially joined them in a virtual daily existence. Further complicating matters is research showing that, at least before the pandemic, remote workers were often passed over for promotion in favor of on-site colleagues. And then there’s the huge existential workplace question, posed by Ignatius: “What is the point of an office at this point?”

Managers have a key role in navigating all these crosscurrents, Neeley emphasized. “We have to think differently on how to bring the group together to gel now,” she said, emphasizing the importance of feedback. “People want predictability ... and predictability around the big picture overall,” she said. “So we have to connect people to the big picture because they feel a little bit lost. They don’t know what’s happening at the mothership, so connecting people to the big picture as much as you can on a regular basis. And finally, performance feedback. Remote workers crave performance feedback. They have more questions about, ‘Am I doing okay? Are things okay?’ So we have to be so disciplined about this piece and developing people, as well.”

Both managers and employees face other pitfalls, including tech exhaustion and overwork, with Neeley and Ignatius citing previous studies showing remote workers have demonstrated higher productivity but also longer working hours. “Untrained and unchecked, remote work can go wrong,” Neeley said. “I use the term hyper-productivity when I describe productivity gone wrong. This is where our work and non-work lives get blurred to the point where we don’t know where we start and where things end because we’re literally commuting for five minutes,” she said.

“The other thing is, we’ve replaced some of our commute times with work. And on average, we’re seeing that people are working 6.8 hours more per week. If you think about seven hours, that’s like a whole day, so it’s so much more work. And leaders need to really put those guardrails up, because people are getting stressed and burned out,” Neeley said.

She added: “It’s time to recreate and revise culture–and take the best that remote work and virtuality offers, while at the same time overcoming some of the challenges. One of the most important things that I see, and the failure points that I’m worried about, is around this entire mindset shift that needs to take place. Leaders of organizations are still stuck with the idea that we’re going back to something.”

A key practice that will have to move forward is assessing and measuring performance. “How do you do that when you don’t see people?,” Neeley asked. To refocus those parameters, she said, “we need to completely rethink how we measure performance predicated on outcomes and not process. We need to trust people and help people trust people. We need to bring the logic of global organizations, even if we’re not global–which means how we think about time, how we think about space, how we think about connection, how we think about dispersion, how we think about compensation.”

Sheila Flynn is an Austin-based journalist who has written for the Associated Press, the Sunday Independent, the Irish Daily Mail and the Irish Times. She is a graduate of the University of Notre Dame.


RELATED STORIES

The Keys to Employee Engagement in Today’s Workplace

A positive company culture can power strong engagement with employees, with business yielding benefits like higher productivity and profitability. As senior director of talent management and organizational effectiveness at The Home Depot, Joe Garcia knew the secret to strong employee engagement came with finding the right employees first.“When we start to go deep into trying to understand what drives engagement, we often think about the environment, the effectiveness of leaders, and the work-life balance,” Garcia said. “But we don't always spend a ton of time thinking if we are selecting folks that are likely to be a good fit for the role and the culture of the company.”With approximately 475,000 associates, Garcia discovered his high-performing associates had distinguishable qualities such as having a high desire to help others and openness to learning.“That propensity and desire to learn was a big predictor of success so we built assessments and structured interview guides with questions that are attempting to measure not only your experience but also your culture fit with clear anchors,” said Garcia.At From Day One’s March virtual conference, Garcia and a panel of other leaders joined Lydia Dishman, senior editor of growth and engagement at Fast Company, in a discussion on how to effectively drive employee engagement in today’s workplace.Providing Employees with Learning OpportunitiesWith a remote workforce, vice president of human resources and recruiting at Allied Universal Security Services, Kimberly Ardo-Eisenbeis knew she would have to find creative strategies to engage her employees.After trial-and-error of different strategies, Ardo-Eisenbeis found offering small micro-learning opportunities was the sweet spot for her employees.“We have an amazing talent and development team that puts together these small micro-learnings that are five to ten minutes long. These nuggets are meaningful and can help engage our employees because these are not just checking-the-box learning, but information that somebody can then act on,” Ardo-Eisenbeis said.For Ardo-Eisenbeis, the key was to value the quality of engagement over quantity. “Rather than sitting someone in a classroom or having virtual learnings where there’s not much appetite, we learned that these small micro-learnings can still fill the bucket,” Ardo-Eisenbeis said. “When it comes to learning, it’s not always about quantity but about the quality and the intention, and what somebody can do with that information.”The group of leaders spoke on a panel during From Day One's March virtual conference about energizing workers (photo by From Day One)Learning and development can also be powerful drivers in employee engagement, with 80% of employees reporting that learning and development opportunities would help them feel more engaged at work.Wielding learning as a form of engagement can also help benefit other areas of the business, Shawn Overcast, chief insights officer of Explorance said.“Learning matters as a driver of engagement and career development. Not only does learning aim to help us build skills and help to inform somebody's career development, but it also allows us to listen,” Overcast said. “As we formally bring people together and ask them questions about their experience, [learning] acts as a listening hub and an opportunity to network which can support functional collaboration, relationship building, and further build trust and psychological safety in the organization.”Charting Different Career PathsThe shift from traditional linear career paths to non-linear paths is increasingly more common, with 52% of U.S. workers having considered a job change, and as many as 44% having actual plans to make the change last year. The finding is in line with what commercial real estate company, Unibail-Rodamco-Westfield, currently is seeing.“We lean into internal mobility and allow people to move from one function to an entirely different one. So, we’ve seen big bold moves, like people moving from finance to IT or people moving from marketing to sales,” Isobel Lincoln, senior vice president of human resources, said.Allowing workers to explore different career paths can prove beneficial to companies as it allows employees to continue to grow and learn new skill sets while remaining at a single organization. Workers who have moved internally have a 64% chance of remaining with an organization after three years, according to LinkedIn data. In contrast, only 45% of employees who haven’t moved internally have a smaller likelihood of staying with the company after three years.Lincoln already sees the benefits of internal mobility in her company. “More than half of my HR team have come from other parts of the business so it's working for us because we get to retain those employees for much longer.”Wanly Chen is a writer and poet based in New York City.

Wanly Chen | March 26, 2024

For Hourly Workers, Building a Culture That’s Motivating and Gratifying

Monigo Saygbay-Hallie, Ph.D., is the chief people officer at Checkers & Rally’s Drive-In Restaurants. She reflects that at 15, she cried on the first day of her first job at Mr. Jim’s Pizza due to stress because the telephone was ringing off the hook as a steady stream of customers called in their delivery orders.However, by her third month on the job, she was an assistant manager closing the restaurant by herself on Sundays. The woman who owned that Mr. Jim’s Pizza franchise “believed I had more potential than I thought I had,” she told moderator Lydia Dishman in a fireside chat at From Day One’s March virtual conference.“She gave me more responsibility each and every day. That’s what I love about the restaurant industry. They take chances on many people,” she said. Saygbay-Hallie would then go into HR because “I learned that I really love the human element of what drives businesses in developing and growing people and making them better leaders.”Motivating Hourly WorkersWhen it comes to motivating employees, managers should remember that “at the end of the day, everybody wants the same thing, whether you are frying fries at the grill or developing a marketing strategy,” she said. “You want to be heard and valued, and you want an opportunity to grow.”In the back of the house of a Checkers and Rally’s restaurant, “we have huddle meetings every day where we talk about how we’ve made sales,” Saygbay-Hallie said. “It’s like, ‘Great job, thank you.’ It’s high-fives.”The company’s IT team sends an email every week to the manager of each restaurant to let them know which employees at that store have upcoming birthdays or anniversaries. The email also offers ideas on how to celebrate the milestone, such as cupcakes.A Sense of BelongingWhen workers feel like they belong, “they put that extra effort in, that extra love in your food,” Saygbay-Hallie said.Lydia Dishman interviewed Monigo Saygbay-Hallie of Checkers & Rally's during the fireside chat (photo by From Day One)Checkers and Rally’s does a quarterly survey, asking employees if they feel like they belong, if they appreciate their supervisor, and if their supervisor appreciates them.“That measures our culture,” Saygbay-Hallie said. “And from that survey, we then go back and develop action plans, talking with each of the employees about what we can do more or less in order to make this a place where they want to stay.”Communication is KeyMost of Checkers and Rally’s management hires are internal promotions, “so they were once a team member in that very store,” Saygbay-Hallie said.These fledgling managers need to learn how to communicate with the employees they are now supervising, she said. For example, they must be able to instruct team members on how to do their jobs and have conversations with them about their performance. Therefore, Checkers and Rally’s created the Leadership of the Future program, which teaches all these skills.One thing Checkers and Rally’s teaches its managers is how to recognize when a team member might be struggling with something in their personal life that is affecting their job performance.“You want to have grace, but you also want to have standards,” she said. “So, it’s really communicating if you see someone come in late constantly, or if they’re not giving their best effort, it’s a one-on-one conversation.” This allows managers the opportunity to offer support rather than blaming the employee.Encouraging Career DevelopmentShift managers and assistant managers at Checkers and Rally’s restaurants do quarterly check-ins with their team. Saygbay-Hallie says 75% of those discussions are about employee performance, while 25% is centered on career development.“In my visits to the restaurants, I’ve talked to women, in the spirit of Women’s History Month, about them moving on to be a keyholder, where they're a general manager,” Saygbay-Hallie said.Some hourly employees who speak English as a second language say they don’t think they have the English skills to communicate as a manager, she said. That’s why Checkers and Rally’s offers free language classes.“We don’t want any barriers to anyone,” Saygbay-Hallie said.Mary Pieper is a freelance writer based in Mason City, Iowa.

Mary Pieper | March 26, 2024

Boosting Employee Motivation by Focusing on Internal Mobility

The Great Reshuffle may have officially reached its end. The labor market is tightening, voluntary job quits have been steadily declining over the last year, and large-scale layoffs have spooked some would-be job hoppers. Recruiting firm Robert Half found that 36% of workers plan to look for a new job in 2024. Last year, that figure was 49%.Workers seem keen to stay where they are for the moment, yet there’s no indication that employees are willing to put the brakes on their careers. They may stall anyway. According to a 2024 report from Gartner, 89% of HR leaders say career paths organization are unclear, and fewer than one in three workers say they know how to progress their career in the next five years.Shannon Flynn is VP of corporate human resources at global industrial tech firm Fortive Corporation. She’s worried about employees’ lack of direction, and wonders if HR could be standing in the way.“We have so much opportunity to move people around, but the employees don’t see it,” Flynn said during From Day One’s March virtual conference on energizing workers. “The starting point for all of us should be, ‘what’s getting in the way of our employees having visibility into that, and what can we do to remove it?’”Turning Networks into Opportunities“A lot of the CHROs and heads of talent we work with are starting to help their colleagues think more like a career lattice than a career ladder,” said Dave Wilkin, founder of digital networking platform Ten Thousand Coffees, who joined Flynn and leaders for the panel discussion. But a career lattice doesn’t form by accident, Wilkin said. Landing those next moves–whether vertical or lateral–has a lot to do with who you know. “Ultimately, opportunities are found through networks.”The panelists discussed the topic "Boosting Employee Motivation by Focusing on Internal Mobility" during the virtual conference (photo by From Day One)Opportunity networks aren’t necessarily equitable; they are often sorted by race or gender or and especially seniority. According to data from LinkedIn, in 2024 internal mobility rates are up 30% since 2021, yet it’s people at the manager and director levels who are most likely to move–more than twice as likely as individual contributors. To extend opportunities to all, Wilkin says, networks cannot be accidental. Employers must help workers form relationships across the organization.Envisioning New Career MapsTo help workers see what they can reach for, companies once relied on career mobility maps, but those quickly expire, said Sarah Waltman, VP of talent management and organizational development at dental products maker Dentsply Sirona. Waltman’s answer to rigid maps is a flexible exploration tool. “We provide a template that [employees] can use to explore the organization through networking, through conversation, through the tools we have in place for sponsorship, mentorship, or coaching. It’s almost like a treasure map, where they can explore different methods to discover other things that they could do.”Fortive, which is the parent of more than a dozen companies, did give career mapping a go, but the company wasn’t concerned about traditional models. “The arrows were pointing everywhere,” said Flynn, describing the final product. “If I start here as a financial planning and analysis person, my next move could be a senior person in the same role at the same size company, it could be the same role at a larger company, or it could be this other thing. What we showed was movement up, down, back and forth, and diagonal.”Flynn based the maps on the real paths its employees had taken, then invited leaders to share their stories at work functions, “and it quickly demonstrated that none of them took a purely vertical path,” she said. “All of them had taken some kind of diversionary role that allowed them to get experience, it made them better in that new role.”Building the ExperienceWaltman encourages those wanting to climb the ladder to look for extracurriculars to build their skills. Employee resource groups, or ERGs, have at times been criticized for being non-promotable work, yet Dentsply Sirona considers them leadership skill-builders. “We have a large participation in employee resource groups,” Waltman said. “So what I encourage you to do is, if you’re trying to build management skills, but you’re not a manager, why not become a leader of one of these groups?”Merck’s global head of integrated learning experiences, Teresa Zeller, surveys employees three to four times per year about the learning and development opportunities they’ve sought. “We have stressed in our organization that the breadth helps you to ultimately get to a higher altitude,” she said. The message is reflected in the survey answers. Merck’s workforce uses everything from company-sponsored learning and external training programs to gig and short-term assignments, mentorship, sponsorship, knowledge-sharing, conferences, and ERGs to build careers.“As people start to see that the individuals who are going broad are actually moving in the organization, not only does it broaden their experiences, but it gives them meaningful work, it gives them bounce,” Zeller said. “Oftentimes they find an area they would have never stumbled into before, then they decide, ‘this is actually the career for me.’”Emily McCrary-Ruiz-Esparza is a freelance journalist and From Day One contributing editor who writes about work, the job market, and women’s experiences in the workplace. Her work has appeared in the BBC, The Washington Post, Quartz, Fast Company, and Digiday’s Worklife.

Emily McCrary-Ruiz-Esparza | March 25, 2024